The Dark Side of Recruitment: Exposing the “Fake Candidate” Problem

The issue of “fake candidates” in recruitment poses significant challenges, especially in sectors like technology where remote work and global hiring are prevalent. The following analysis builds on the provided text, offering deeper context, applications, and best practices for recruiters and sourcers in the Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO) industry. Additionally, strategies to increase the likelihood of hiring candidates who are well-suited for and likely to remain in their roles are suggested.

Below I list some of the most salient patterns professional recruiters share when suspecting of fake candidates.

Common Patterns of Fake Candidates

Inconsistent Identity:

Names inconsistent with accents, educational background, or other personal details may indicate falsified credentials. For example, a name like “Samuel Hutchinson” paired with an accent typical of a non-English-speaking region could warrant further verification. However, recruiters must be cautious not to stereotype; legitimate global candidates may adopt names to integrate better into foreign markets, but in general, this incongruence may give you a reason to be alert.

This is why using advanced identity verification tools like automated document validation (e.g., verifying passports or national IDs) combined with a culturally sensitive approach to avoid alienating genuine candidates might be the best line of defense for this factor.

Best Practices: Train recruiters on implicit biases to ensure identity concerns are handled with professionalism and cultural competence.

Technical Issues with Video Interviews:

Technical difficulties, such as refusing to turn on cameras or use headphones, can be red flags. Some fake candidates use proxies or voice modulation to evade detection.

What to do?

Implement policies requiring video-enabled interviews with robust pre-interview setup checks. Use software to validate IP addresses and ensure the interviewee is in an expected location.

Best Practices: Allow flexibility for legitimate technical issues while maintaining strict protocols to prevent misuse.

Excuses for Identification:

Genuine candidates are generally willing to provide identification. Repeated excuses signal potential fraud, such as using a proxy to attend the interview or hiding their true identity.

For instance, you may integrate ID verification into the initial application process. If possible, you may also use software that encrypts and securely stores this data to ensure candidate privacy.

Best Practices: Notify candidates in advance of identification requirements to eliminate last-minute delays.

Incomplete Online Presence:

When a candidate lacks a professional photo or minimal activity on LinkedIn might suggest that a profile is fabricated. Legitimate professionals typically maintain active online profiles, especially in tech.

One go-to platforms for assessing the candidate is LinkedIn Recruiter to cross-check profiles, endorsements, and activity. Encourage candidates to share a portfolio or GitHub link to validate technical expertise or any project portfolio that is relevant to their application.

Best Practices: Offer to help candidates build a professional profile, signaling the importance of transparency in the hiring process.

Unusual Requests:

Finally, some people might request for non-standard accommodations or equipment ‘for them to do the job’ which might indicate ulterior motives, such as needing specific hardware to hide technical shortcomings.

It is important, thus, to standardize technology and resources requirements for interviews and onboarding while providing reasonable accommodations for verified candidates.

Best Practices: Be clear in job descriptions about equipment provided and expected from candidates to set mutual expectations.

These patterns are not easy hurdles to overcome so I am including some more strategies for identifying fake candidates in your recruiting process.

Strategies for Identifying Fake Candidates

1. Conduct Video Interviews:
   • Context: Video interviews allow recruiters to verify that the person matches their submitted photo or profile.
   • Applications: Use platforms that offer real-time facial recognition and video recording for future verification.
   • Best Practices: Schedule a brief pre-screening call to address potential technical issues before the formal interview.
2. Cross-Verify Information:
   • Context: Discrepancies in resumes and profiles often indicate false claims.
   • Applications: Utilize background-check services to verify employment, education, and certifications. Automate this process for efficiency.
   • Best Practices: Educate recruiters on spotting red flags, such as mismatched employment dates or generic job descriptions.
3. Listen for Delayed Responses:
   • Context: Delayed answers might indicate that the candidate is being fed answers during the interview.
   • Applications: Use structured interviews with time-sensitive, situational questions that require quick thinking.
   • Best Practices: Incorporate hands-on assessments or real-time problem-solving tasks to evaluate genuine expertise.
4. Use Technology Wisely:
   • Context: AI-driven platforms can streamline the screening process by identifying anomalies in resumes or applications.
   • Applications: Invest in applicant tracking systems (ATS) with AI capabilities to flag inconsistencies automatically.
   • Best Practices: Regularly update the AI tools with fraud detection algorithms and real-world examples of fake profiles.
5. Trust Your Instincts:
   • Context: Experienced recruiters often develop a sixth sense for identifying dishonest behavior.
   • Applications: Train new recruiters on pattern recognition and offer mentorship from senior team members.
   • Best Practices: Create a checklist of warning signs to ensure instincts are backed by objective criteria.

---

Additional Best Practices for RPO Recruiters

1. Behavioral Assessments:
   • Use behavioral and psychometric assessments to gauge a candidate’s soft skills and cultural fit. This reduces the risk of hiring candidates who may leave due to a lack of alignment with the role or organization.
2. Work Sample Tests:
   • Ask candidates to complete tasks reflective of actual job responsibilities. For example, a developer can provide a sample code, or a marketing professional can create a brief strategy plan.
3. Build Talent Pools:
   • Create a repository of pre-vetted candidates to reduce the dependency on external applicants and streamline future hiring needs.
4. Focus on Retention Metrics:
   • Collaborate with clients to define what makes a candidate successful in their roles. Develop metrics to measure these traits during recruitment.
5. Employer Branding:
   • Highlight the authenticity and professionalism of the hiring process to deter fake candidates and attract genuine talent.
6. Post-Hire Follow-Ups:
   • Conduct periodic check-ins with newly hired employees to ensure their integration and satisfaction, reducing turnover rates.

---

Useful Applications in the RPO Industry

1. Fraud Detection Systems:
   • Develop or invest in systems that detect patterns of fraudulent behavior in resumes and applications.
2. Virtual Reality (VR) Onboarding:
   • Use VR to simulate the workplace environment during the hiring process, which can help filter out less committed candidates.
3. Data Analytics:
   • Analyze historical hiring data to identify trends in fake candidates and refine screening processes.
4. Candidate Nurturing Programs:
   • Maintain relationships with high-potential candidates who were not initially selected, ensuring a reliable pipeline for future roles.

With this curated list I purport to help new recruiters allocate wisely their sourcing and recruiting efforts to deliver high-quality candidates that match their clients’ culture and technical requirements so that their busienss relationship grows stronger.

If you need help sourcing quality talent for your organization or even as a professional who is growing and requires a quality talent to be recruited by professional standards, feel free to contact us to discuss our recruiting solutions.